Should I do EPF voluntary top-up (i-Saraan / Self Contribution) in my late 20s or invest myself?

Question

I'm 28, been reading about topping up my EPF voluntarily on top of the normal deduction, since the dividend has been decent around 5-6%. But some friends say at my age I should take that spare RM500 a month and invest in ASB or an index fund instead for higher returns and more flexibility. For those who've actually done EPF top-ups long term, was it worth locking the money away?

Auntie Retire Devi · Accepted Answer

I've been doing voluntary EPF top-ups of RM300-500 a month for about 5 years and I think it's worth it as one part of your mix, not your whole strategy. The EPF dividend has averaged around 5.5-6% over the long run and it's essentially risk-free with government backing, which ASB partially matches but index funds do not guarantee. The catch you must understand is liquidity, that money is locked until 55 for Account 1 portion, so only top up what you truly won't need. There's also the tax relief of up to RM4,000 combined with your mandatory contribution, and for i-Saraan self-employed folks there's even a government matching incentive. My approach is EPF top-up for the untouchable retirement core, and separate money in more liquid stuff for medium-term goals.

Landlord Uncle Wong · Answer

At 28 with a long horizon, I personally lean towards a low-cost global index fund over EPF top-ups for the extra money. Historically the global equity market has returned around 7-10% over long periods versus EPF's 5-6%, and over 30 years that gap compounds into a massive difference. The flexibility matters too, you can withdraw for a house, emergency, or opportunity, whereas EPF locks it till 55. EPF is great as your baseline forced savings, but for voluntary extra money at your young age I'd take the higher expected return and liquidity. Just be disciplined enough not to touch it, which is the real challenge.

Property Uncle Tan · Answer

One thing from experience, the psychological benefit of EPF's lock-in is real and shouldn't be dismissed. I invest in index funds too but every market crash I get tempted to panic sell or dip in for random wants, whereas my EPF just sits there compounding untouched because I literally cannot access it. That forced discipline has probably made me richer than my slightly-higher-return brokerage account which I keep fiddling with. If you know yourself and you're the type to tinker or panic, EPF's rigidity is a feature not a bug. Match the tool to your own behaviour, not just the theoretical returns.

Civil Servant Encik Azman · Answer

Practical reminder, whatever you choose, do it via auto-deduction so you don't rely on willpower. I set up a standing instruction to top up EPF right after payday through the KWSP i-Akaun and Touch n Go / bank, so the money's gone before I can spend it. The mistake I made early on was doing it manually and I'd always find an excuse to skip that month. Automate it, treat it like a bill, and review your split once a year. Consistency over 30 years matters far more than squeezing an extra 1-2% return.

Auntie Property Lily · Answer

The tax relief angle is what tips it for me and people underestimate this. If you're in the 19-24% tax bracket, topping up EPF to max out the RM4,000 relief effectively gives you an instant return on top of the dividend, because you get real ringgit back at tax time via LHDN. Combine that guaranteed dividend plus the tax saving and it's very hard for an index fund to beat on a risk-adjusted basis for that specific tranche of money. Above the RM4k relief limit, then yes I'd invest elsewhere. So maximise the tax-relief portion in EPF first, then diversify beyond that.

Fresh Grad Wei Xiang · Answer

Don't forget ASB and ASNB fixed-price funds if you're Bumiputera, they've historically paid around 5-6% too and are very liquid, you can redeem within days. For non-Bumi there's ASN variable price funds which are decent but not the same fixed-price magic. The nice thing about ASB versus EPF is you can pull it out anytime for emergencies while still getting comparable returns to EPF. I split mine, EPF for the tax relief portion up to RM4k, and the rest in ASB for flexibility. That way I get the tax benefit and keep some access.

Should I do EPF voluntary top-up (i-Saraan / Self Contribution) in my late 20s or invest myself?

6 contributors answered

Answer this

Related questions

Can I withdraw EPF Account 2 for house down payment and how long does KWSP take to approve?

What's the real experience of paying off your PTPTN loan, salary deduction vs lump sum?

What are the hard lessons of withdrawing EPF Account 2 for a house downpayment

What's it actually like withdrawing from EPF Akaun 3 (Akaun Fleksibel) for the first time?

Constant gastric pain and bloating, should I go government clinic or private GP in Malaysia and what to expect cost wise?

Can I use EPF Account 2 for house downpayment ah?